Summary: An American (also) named Jonathan Safran Foer has traveled to Austria with an aged picture depicting his grandfather with Augustine, the woman who saved his grandfather from the Nazis. With the help of his translator Alex and his driver, Alex's grandfather, Jonathan begins a hunt for Augustine. But this is not a novel that is told chronologically or with a traditional narrative structure. Instead, the story is recounted through Alex's letters to Jonathan after the trip and Alex's own recreation of the narrative, as well as through Jonathan's fictional recreation of his family's history.
Musings: Everything is Illuminated is a very different book--one that, in the beginning, I thought I would hate, but in the end, found difficult to put down. It's a strange combination of the humorous and the tragic, of the real and the not-real, and the in between. It's a book that makes you see life's moments as simultaneous and muddled, and it makes me want to write in run-on sentences.
Alex is a fascinating narrator, and he transforms from hiding in bragging and joking to the most thoughtful character in the novel. He is only partially fluent in English, and he over-uses a thesaurus, so his letters are often a funny mix of pidgin English. I worried the book would lean too heavily on a "haha, look at his strange English," but that really isn't the case at all. Alex and Jonathan's early conversations also provide a lot of humor as they struggle to understand and communicate with one another.
Jonathan's fictional narrative of his family has a folksy, magical realism style to it, which initially turned me off (I think I'm still prejudiced against the style from reading One Hundred Years of Solitude), but was essential to the mood and feeling of the novel at its end.
As one review I read put it, Everything is Illuminated is, at its most simple, a story about the Holocaust, but that barely begins to encapsulate the novel. It's a story about love and memories and the ability to see oneself clearly. It's a book that has so many interwoven parts that it demands a reread but still feels satisfying once finished. It's a book that made me laugh out loud and cry.
I've always loved books, but "adult" life seemed to get in the way. Now I'm making time to read and falling in love all over again.
Sunday, December 12, 2010
Wednesday, December 8, 2010
"Unbroken" by Laura Hillenbrand
Summary: The true story of the life of Louie Zamperini during World War II. Zamperini was an Olympic runner when he joined the Air Force, with the potential of medaling in the next Olympic Games. Switching his life of running for a life in the military, Zamperini worked in the massive B-24 planes. When his plane crashed into the Pacific Ocean during the war, Zamperini spent weeks adrift at sea before being captured by the Japanese. That capture began years of internment and abuse as a prisoner of war.
Musings: Unbroken has been making the rounds on the "best of 2010" book lists, and because I feel like I know little about World War II, I was interested in learning about one man's tale.
Zamperini has a fantastic story, though it's clear from this book that his story is only one of many incredible stories coming out of POWs. There's much in Zamperini's life that brings amazement--his skill as a runner, his ability to survive weeks aboard a life raft, and his endurance of years of torture as a POW.
Hillenbrand has done an exceptional job of bringing various pieces of Zamperini's life together in a cogent and compelling narrative. She portrays a multi-dimensional view of Zamperini, showing his boyhood as a trouble maker, his resilience during the war, and his struggles with PTSD after returning home. Although Zamperini is clearly a brave man, Hillenbrand doesn't hide his dark moments, nor does she glorify the idea of "war heroes."
In fact, one of the issues that most stuck out to me was despite the important justifications for going to war, there was so much senselessness in what happened. For example, Hillenbrand explains the extraordinarily high injury and death rate from accidents, particularly within the air force. Military personnel were more likely to die by mistakes than through combat. This is clearly the case for Zamperini, whose plane goes down while on a rescue mission for another downed plane.
Hillenbrand also details the extraordinary difficulty of POWs adjusting to "normal" life after the war's end. Men who had remained hopeful and alive through the worst circumstances were too traumatized to enjoy the life they had held out for. Zamperini was fortunate to be able to find solace (for him, in God), but undoubtedly many more were unable to.
However, while I enjoyed the story and learned much from Zamperini's experiences, I felt bothered about judging the book itself. One of the things that gnawed at me as I read was the definition of what makes a book "good." I had seen Unbroken on so many "best of" lists that I think I expected something more. When a fiction writer tells an amazing story, we laud them for it, but should we do so for a nonfiction writer? Is Hillenbrand's unquestionable ability to research and pull together so many disparate sources enough? For me, a truly great book has to have something in style and form that sets it apart, and I just didn't see that in Unbroken. The story is clearly told chronologically, and Hillenbrand keeps the narrative moving quickly, investing in strong character detail throughout. However, in the end, the book is still a standard narrative, and because of that, it didn't stand out to me as something special, beyond the extra-ordinariness of the story itself. I don't say this to be critical--I thought the book was very good--but it's not the kind of book that would make a top reading list for me.
P.S. On a separate note, I accidentally requested the large print copy of Unbroken at my library instead of a regular copy. I was worried that the enormously large size of the text would be a distraction, but I found it didn't bother me much (though I didn't like the size of the book because of the large print--it was over 700 pages and quite heavy).
Musings: Unbroken has been making the rounds on the "best of 2010" book lists, and because I feel like I know little about World War II, I was interested in learning about one man's tale.
Zamperini has a fantastic story, though it's clear from this book that his story is only one of many incredible stories coming out of POWs. There's much in Zamperini's life that brings amazement--his skill as a runner, his ability to survive weeks aboard a life raft, and his endurance of years of torture as a POW.
Hillenbrand has done an exceptional job of bringing various pieces of Zamperini's life together in a cogent and compelling narrative. She portrays a multi-dimensional view of Zamperini, showing his boyhood as a trouble maker, his resilience during the war, and his struggles with PTSD after returning home. Although Zamperini is clearly a brave man, Hillenbrand doesn't hide his dark moments, nor does she glorify the idea of "war heroes."
In fact, one of the issues that most stuck out to me was despite the important justifications for going to war, there was so much senselessness in what happened. For example, Hillenbrand explains the extraordinarily high injury and death rate from accidents, particularly within the air force. Military personnel were more likely to die by mistakes than through combat. This is clearly the case for Zamperini, whose plane goes down while on a rescue mission for another downed plane.
Hillenbrand also details the extraordinary difficulty of POWs adjusting to "normal" life after the war's end. Men who had remained hopeful and alive through the worst circumstances were too traumatized to enjoy the life they had held out for. Zamperini was fortunate to be able to find solace (for him, in God), but undoubtedly many more were unable to.
However, while I enjoyed the story and learned much from Zamperini's experiences, I felt bothered about judging the book itself. One of the things that gnawed at me as I read was the definition of what makes a book "good." I had seen Unbroken on so many "best of" lists that I think I expected something more. When a fiction writer tells an amazing story, we laud them for it, but should we do so for a nonfiction writer? Is Hillenbrand's unquestionable ability to research and pull together so many disparate sources enough? For me, a truly great book has to have something in style and form that sets it apart, and I just didn't see that in Unbroken. The story is clearly told chronologically, and Hillenbrand keeps the narrative moving quickly, investing in strong character detail throughout. However, in the end, the book is still a standard narrative, and because of that, it didn't stand out to me as something special, beyond the extra-ordinariness of the story itself. I don't say this to be critical--I thought the book was very good--but it's not the kind of book that would make a top reading list for me.
P.S. On a separate note, I accidentally requested the large print copy of Unbroken at my library instead of a regular copy. I was worried that the enormously large size of the text would be a distraction, but I found it didn't bother me much (though I didn't like the size of the book because of the large print--it was over 700 pages and quite heavy).
Sunday, December 5, 2010
GLBT Reading Challenge Wrap-Up
When I signed up for the GLBT Challenge, I hoped to read not just more books with GLBT characters/authors in general, but in particular, I was looking for YA books that would fit these categories. I think I did fairly well on that this year. I signed up at the lambda level, which was four books, but I ended up reading seven. Here's my list:
- Ash by Malinda Lo
- Luna by Julie Anne Peters
- Libyrinth by Pearl North
- Will Grayson, Will Grayson by John Green and David Levithan
- Wildthorn by Jane Eagland
- Room by Emma Donoghue
- A Room of One's Own by Virginia Woolf
Of the seven, Room was definitely my favorite, though there are no GLBT characters and I didn't know Donoghue was a lesbian until after I had read the book. A Room of One's Own was a close second, and Will Grayson, Will Grayson was my favorite of the YA.
Although I found I mostly had to actively seek out books with GLBT protagonists, I was happy to see a number of books I read positively portrayed GLBT secondary characters. I didn't count these books towards the challenge, but they include:
- Zombies vs. Unicorns by various authors
- The Book of Lost Things by John Connolly
- The Shipping News by E. Annie Proulx
- The Ask and the Answer and Monsters of Men by Patrick Ness
I'm definitely glad I did this challenge, though I'll admit I put more time into searching for books in the beginning of the year than in the end. I spent a significant amount of time in the beginning looking for GLBT fantasy/sci-fi, but had a hard time finding much. It's something I'll continue to keep an eye out for.
- Ash by Malinda Lo
- Luna by Julie Anne Peters
- Libyrinth by Pearl North
- Will Grayson, Will Grayson by John Green and David Levithan
- Wildthorn by Jane Eagland
- Room by Emma Donoghue
- A Room of One's Own by Virginia Woolf
Of the seven, Room was definitely my favorite, though there are no GLBT characters and I didn't know Donoghue was a lesbian until after I had read the book. A Room of One's Own was a close second, and Will Grayson, Will Grayson was my favorite of the YA.
Although I found I mostly had to actively seek out books with GLBT protagonists, I was happy to see a number of books I read positively portrayed GLBT secondary characters. I didn't count these books towards the challenge, but they include:
- Zombies vs. Unicorns by various authors
- The Book of Lost Things by John Connolly
- The Shipping News by E. Annie Proulx
- The Ask and the Answer and Monsters of Men by Patrick Ness
I'm definitely glad I did this challenge, though I'll admit I put more time into searching for books in the beginning of the year than in the end. I spent a significant amount of time in the beginning looking for GLBT fantasy/sci-fi, but had a hard time finding much. It's something I'll continue to keep an eye out for.
Friday, December 3, 2010
"The Remains of the Day" by Kazuo Ishiguro
Summary: Mr. Stevens, an aging English butler, once served Lord Darlington at the height of the Lord's prominence, looking over a large house staff and overseeing events involving important political figures. But Lord Darlington has been dead several years, and an American gentleman now owns the property. When Stevens' American employer leaves for several weeks, he suggests Stevens take a holiday. As Stevens takes a motoring trip, he looks back on his many years of service, facing the truth of his employer and his service.
Musings: Remains of the Day is probably one of the most thoughtfully characterized book I have ever read, and in this small novel, which is almost all introspection, I found myself more engrossed than in any action book I've read.
The Remains of the Day is a quiet novel, much like Ishiguro's Never Let Me Go. Its strength lies in the way Ishiguro absolutely makes you believe you are listening to a real English butler named Stevens. Stevens is an absolutely convincing character, and because of this, his experiences are all the more heartbreaking. Stevens is a man who has dedicated himself to executing his profession to perfection. But this all-consuming dedication has been his biggest downfall. In seeing himself as a butler above all else, and in holding himself to expectations higher than anyone else's, he has sacrificed relationships (with his father, a housekeeper named Miss Kenton), intellectual vigor, and enjoyment of life. He has been a martyr for a cause no one but himself supports. And this is all the more sad because Stevens refuses to acknowledge it; he stubbornly defends his choices, even though it's painfully obvious to the reader that his has not truly been a life well-spent.
Stevens narrates the novel in first person, and it's easy to want to empathize with him. His dedication to his job is admirable, and he holds himself to high standards. But it's soon apparent that though Stevens is good at his job, he is not good at being human. He is inconsiderate and uncaring of others' feelings; he rejects friendly conversation, and he holds no room for human fallacy--except in the case of his employer, for whom he mostly overlooks mistakes. He is someone who, at this point in his life, has no friends, no family, and years dedicated to an employer now despised by most.
The Remains of the Day is a beautiful novel, and one I would highly recommend.
***This book qualifies for the POC Reading Challenge and the Books of the Century Challenge.
Musings: Remains of the Day is probably one of the most thoughtfully characterized book I have ever read, and in this small novel, which is almost all introspection, I found myself more engrossed than in any action book I've read.
The Remains of the Day is a quiet novel, much like Ishiguro's Never Let Me Go. Its strength lies in the way Ishiguro absolutely makes you believe you are listening to a real English butler named Stevens. Stevens is an absolutely convincing character, and because of this, his experiences are all the more heartbreaking. Stevens is a man who has dedicated himself to executing his profession to perfection. But this all-consuming dedication has been his biggest downfall. In seeing himself as a butler above all else, and in holding himself to expectations higher than anyone else's, he has sacrificed relationships (with his father, a housekeeper named Miss Kenton), intellectual vigor, and enjoyment of life. He has been a martyr for a cause no one but himself supports. And this is all the more sad because Stevens refuses to acknowledge it; he stubbornly defends his choices, even though it's painfully obvious to the reader that his has not truly been a life well-spent.
Stevens narrates the novel in first person, and it's easy to want to empathize with him. His dedication to his job is admirable, and he holds himself to high standards. But it's soon apparent that though Stevens is good at his job, he is not good at being human. He is inconsiderate and uncaring of others' feelings; he rejects friendly conversation, and he holds no room for human fallacy--except in the case of his employer, for whom he mostly overlooks mistakes. He is someone who, at this point in his life, has no friends, no family, and years dedicated to an employer now despised by most.
The Remains of the Day is a beautiful novel, and one I would highly recommend.
***This book qualifies for the POC Reading Challenge and the Books of the Century Challenge.
Monday, November 29, 2010
"The World According to Garp" by John Irving
Summary: A story of the life of T.S. Garp, the son of famed nurse, author, and feminist Jenny Garp, who would become a famous writer himself.
Musings: I've only read two books by Irving--this and A Prayer for Owen Meany--and they're a lot a like. I don't say this as criticism, but rather because I think the easiest way to understand what The World According to Garp is like is to have read another one of Irving's books.
A World According to Garp is populated by crazy and bizarre characters who nonetheless are so intricately drawn as to feel real (there's something Garp says about fiction being realer than reality, which certainly applies). Similarly, the events that happen in the book are too fantastical to believe (particularly the tragedy) while also making complete sense within the context of the book. There's no real plot arc to the story, and it would be difficult to summarize the novel's plot (which is why I didn't even try in the summary above). Nonetheless, the reader is drawn into the story.
There's a lot to think through after finishing A World According to Garp, and I almost think I'd rather just be left with the finished story. Because Garp is a writer, much of the book concerns Garp's craft of writing. However, those comments on writing are part of the very structure of A World According to Garp itself. In essence, Irving is Garp as Irving writes the book, so the reader is left with the feeling of reading Garp and reading about Garp at the same time. It's all very meta.
But, the book can also be read without thinking too deeply about multiple levels, and there's plenty of humor, sex, violence, tragedy, and love to keep it afloat.
Musings: I've only read two books by Irving--this and A Prayer for Owen Meany--and they're a lot a like. I don't say this as criticism, but rather because I think the easiest way to understand what The World According to Garp is like is to have read another one of Irving's books.
A World According to Garp is populated by crazy and bizarre characters who nonetheless are so intricately drawn as to feel real (there's something Garp says about fiction being realer than reality, which certainly applies). Similarly, the events that happen in the book are too fantastical to believe (particularly the tragedy) while also making complete sense within the context of the book. There's no real plot arc to the story, and it would be difficult to summarize the novel's plot (which is why I didn't even try in the summary above). Nonetheless, the reader is drawn into the story.
There's a lot to think through after finishing A World According to Garp, and I almost think I'd rather just be left with the finished story. Because Garp is a writer, much of the book concerns Garp's craft of writing. However, those comments on writing are part of the very structure of A World According to Garp itself. In essence, Irving is Garp as Irving writes the book, so the reader is left with the feeling of reading Garp and reading about Garp at the same time. It's all very meta.
But, the book can also be read without thinking too deeply about multiple levels, and there's plenty of humor, sex, violence, tragedy, and love to keep it afloat.
Sunday, November 21, 2010
"A Room of One's Own" by Virginia Woolf
Summary: Woolf's essay on "women and fiction," in which she argues that in order for women to create, they need an income of five hundred pounds a year and a room in which they can write.
Musings: I somehow never was exposed to Woolf's classic essay before, and I regret that, though I think this reading came at a perfect time in my life. I'm not a terribly observant reader of most books, and I had to force myself to highlight, comment, and reflect when reading assigned works in college. However, as I read A Room of One's Own for the first time, I cursed the fact that I was reading a library copy. I was dying to mark lines and jot down my thoughts as I read. I turned over particular sentences in my head, read them aloud to my husband, and reread whole sections. I had to pull out a notepad in order to copy down all the gems I wanted to remember. In short, this fabulous feminist essay not only exposes the state of women in 1928, when Woolf was writing, but it also sheds significant light on the fight for equality between the sexes today.
Woolf's primary purpose in the essay is to address the lack of women writers throughout history and to understand what is necessary for a person to create fiction. One of her most potent arguments is that a person must have financial security in order to create. She notes, "Intellectual freedom depends upon material things. Poetry depends upon intellectual freedom. And women have always been poor, not for two hundred years merely, but from the beginning of time. Women have had less intellectual freedom than the sons of Athenian slaves. Women, then, have not had a dog's chance of writing poetry" (106). But it is not only the lack of financial means that have kept women from writing. Woolf argues that is is also the lack of history of women's writing from which to draw on and the lack of social support. Even for poor men, the world says, "Write if you choose; it makes no difference to me," but to women, "the world said with a guffaw, Write? What's the good of your writing?" (52). Woolf recognizes the popular conception that truly great writers produce regardless of circumstance, but she breaks down that false ideal easily.
A Room of One's Own is set during an interesting point in history, a time in which women had recently won the right to vote and were increasingly allowed access to wider range of educational and vocational opportunities. But, greater equality also results in a stronger backlash. Life is difficult, Woolf says, and self-confidence can come most easily by asserting one's superiority over another. So even as women were given more rights, their work and abilities were also being increasingly disparaged. Woolf argues, "Possibly when the professor insisted a little too emphatically upon the inferiority of women, he was concerned not with their inferiority, but with his own superiority. That was what he was protecting rather hot-headedly and with too much emphasis, because it was a jewel to him of the rarest price. ... How can we generate this imponderable quality [of self-confidence], which is yet so invaluable, most quickly? By thinking that other people are inferior to oneself" (34-35).
As I mentioned above, many of Woolf's arguments still hold sway today. Women still make, on average, less than men, and it is a lack of financial freedom that hampers greater equality. Although there are many more opportunities for women artists, there are still many arenas in which women lack a history and support network, and as a result, women are underrepresented. Even Woolf's discussion of the way in which women in literature are only depicted in relationship to men is still evident in many popular stories (just see the continued use of the "Bechdel test").
I had read the introduction to my edition of the essay first, which was a mistake, because it made me think Woolf's piece would be difficult and indecipherable, when in fact I found it especially accessible and pointed. A Room of One's Own is certainly a piece I want to return to, and I also hope to try some of Woolf's fiction in the near future.
***This book qualifies for the GLBT Reading Challenge 2010 and the Books of the Century Challenge.
Musings: I somehow never was exposed to Woolf's classic essay before, and I regret that, though I think this reading came at a perfect time in my life. I'm not a terribly observant reader of most books, and I had to force myself to highlight, comment, and reflect when reading assigned works in college. However, as I read A Room of One's Own for the first time, I cursed the fact that I was reading a library copy. I was dying to mark lines and jot down my thoughts as I read. I turned over particular sentences in my head, read them aloud to my husband, and reread whole sections. I had to pull out a notepad in order to copy down all the gems I wanted to remember. In short, this fabulous feminist essay not only exposes the state of women in 1928, when Woolf was writing, but it also sheds significant light on the fight for equality between the sexes today.
Woolf's primary purpose in the essay is to address the lack of women writers throughout history and to understand what is necessary for a person to create fiction. One of her most potent arguments is that a person must have financial security in order to create. She notes, "Intellectual freedom depends upon material things. Poetry depends upon intellectual freedom. And women have always been poor, not for two hundred years merely, but from the beginning of time. Women have had less intellectual freedom than the sons of Athenian slaves. Women, then, have not had a dog's chance of writing poetry" (106). But it is not only the lack of financial means that have kept women from writing. Woolf argues that is is also the lack of history of women's writing from which to draw on and the lack of social support. Even for poor men, the world says, "Write if you choose; it makes no difference to me," but to women, "the world said with a guffaw, Write? What's the good of your writing?" (52). Woolf recognizes the popular conception that truly great writers produce regardless of circumstance, but she breaks down that false ideal easily.
A Room of One's Own is set during an interesting point in history, a time in which women had recently won the right to vote and were increasingly allowed access to wider range of educational and vocational opportunities. But, greater equality also results in a stronger backlash. Life is difficult, Woolf says, and self-confidence can come most easily by asserting one's superiority over another. So even as women were given more rights, their work and abilities were also being increasingly disparaged. Woolf argues, "Possibly when the professor insisted a little too emphatically upon the inferiority of women, he was concerned not with their inferiority, but with his own superiority. That was what he was protecting rather hot-headedly and with too much emphasis, because it was a jewel to him of the rarest price. ... How can we generate this imponderable quality [of self-confidence], which is yet so invaluable, most quickly? By thinking that other people are inferior to oneself" (34-35).
As I mentioned above, many of Woolf's arguments still hold sway today. Women still make, on average, less than men, and it is a lack of financial freedom that hampers greater equality. Although there are many more opportunities for women artists, there are still many arenas in which women lack a history and support network, and as a result, women are underrepresented. Even Woolf's discussion of the way in which women in literature are only depicted in relationship to men is still evident in many popular stories (just see the continued use of the "Bechdel test").
I had read the introduction to my edition of the essay first, which was a mistake, because it made me think Woolf's piece would be difficult and indecipherable, when in fact I found it especially accessible and pointed. A Room of One's Own is certainly a piece I want to return to, and I also hope to try some of Woolf's fiction in the near future.
***This book qualifies for the GLBT Reading Challenge 2010 and the Books of the Century Challenge.
Thursday, November 18, 2010
"The Devil's Sword" by Douglas E. Richards
***This is the 100th book I've read this year!
Summary: Kevin has recently discovered a passion for fencing, and he's excited to attend a large regional tournament at Nellis Air Force Base with his friends and fellow fencers, Ben and Rachel. However, the three young competitors have no idea that arms dealers intent on stealing the ultimate weapon from the U.S. government are also at the tournament and have their eye on the fencers. Kevin, Ben, and Rachel find themselves unwillingly drawn into a plan that could jeopardize the entire country's safety.
Musings: The Devil's Sword belongs to a genre that I never read--middle grade spy/adventure fiction. So I read this book for one simple reason. It has fencing in it.
As I've mentioned before, I fenced in college and have since been fascinated by the sport. However, while there's plenty of literature involving sword fighting, there are very few books which include fencing as a competitive sport. When I heard about this book through my college fencing listserve, I was eager to try it out. From the summary alone I knew the book would not be completely up my alley--fencers stop arms dealers!?--but I hoped the smart inclusion of the sport would win me over.
In the end, it's difficult for me to talk about the book fairly, as I want to acknowledge its weaknesses while also refraining from being overly harsh to a book that I would never normally have considered.
So, first, the bad in short. The story is cliche and cheesy, the characters are stock, and there is a serious problem of "telling" instead of "showing." There's no real style--just a story explained over the course of the book.
However, there are also goods. The fencing is realistically portrayed. One of the problems in writing books about fencing is that fencing, unlike more popular sports like basketball or football, has complicated rules, procedures, and uniforms that the lay person is not familiar with. Richards does, then, go into long explanations about the sport (there's an especially large info dump in the first chapter), but it's accurate and interesting information. The novel's especially good at showing how fencing can be appealing to people just like Kevin--slightly nerdy types who might want to be active but not be interested in traditional "jock" sports.
I was also worried that a book involving fencers facing arms dealers would inevitably lead to a dramatic sword fight between a 14-year-old and a villain. As I've told the many people who have asked over the years, fencing in no way prepares you to actually fight anyone--sword or not. Again, I was pleasantly surprised. The book begins with this fabulous quote from Bruce Lee which sets the tone for the rest of the book:
The Devil's Sword would be a good book for young people (middle to late elementary, probably) interested in spy books and/or fencing. I also think it might be a good book for a child who might be interested in fencing, as it portrays the sport in a positive light.
Summary: Kevin has recently discovered a passion for fencing, and he's excited to attend a large regional tournament at Nellis Air Force Base with his friends and fellow fencers, Ben and Rachel. However, the three young competitors have no idea that arms dealers intent on stealing the ultimate weapon from the U.S. government are also at the tournament and have their eye on the fencers. Kevin, Ben, and Rachel find themselves unwillingly drawn into a plan that could jeopardize the entire country's safety.
Musings: The Devil's Sword belongs to a genre that I never read--middle grade spy/adventure fiction. So I read this book for one simple reason. It has fencing in it.
As I've mentioned before, I fenced in college and have since been fascinated by the sport. However, while there's plenty of literature involving sword fighting, there are very few books which include fencing as a competitive sport. When I heard about this book through my college fencing listserve, I was eager to try it out. From the summary alone I knew the book would not be completely up my alley--fencers stop arms dealers!?--but I hoped the smart inclusion of the sport would win me over.
In the end, it's difficult for me to talk about the book fairly, as I want to acknowledge its weaknesses while also refraining from being overly harsh to a book that I would never normally have considered.
So, first, the bad in short. The story is cliche and cheesy, the characters are stock, and there is a serious problem of "telling" instead of "showing." There's no real style--just a story explained over the course of the book.
However, there are also goods. The fencing is realistically portrayed. One of the problems in writing books about fencing is that fencing, unlike more popular sports like basketball or football, has complicated rules, procedures, and uniforms that the lay person is not familiar with. Richards does, then, go into long explanations about the sport (there's an especially large info dump in the first chapter), but it's accurate and interesting information. The novel's especially good at showing how fencing can be appealing to people just like Kevin--slightly nerdy types who might want to be active but not be interested in traditional "jock" sports.
I was also worried that a book involving fencers facing arms dealers would inevitably lead to a dramatic sword fight between a 14-year-old and a villain. As I've told the many people who have asked over the years, fencing in no way prepares you to actually fight anyone--sword or not. Again, I was pleasantly surprised. The book begins with this fabulous quote from Bruce Lee which sets the tone for the rest of the book:
"If someone comes at you with a sword, run if you can. Kung Fu doesn't always work."Although fencing provides the background for the book, and the kids' skills, developed in fencing, do play a part in their interactions with the arms dealers, there's no silly sword fight to the death. In fact, as the book continues, fencing begins to play a less significant role in the novel. I was actually rather disappointed when the novel moved away from the sport and simply into a traditional kids' spy story.
The Devil's Sword would be a good book for young people (middle to late elementary, probably) interested in spy books and/or fencing. I also think it might be a good book for a child who might be interested in fencing, as it portrays the sport in a positive light.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





