Sunday, March 6, 2011

"Gardens of Water" by Alan Drew

Summary: After a catastrophic earthquake in Turkey, two very different families are forever linked.  Sinan is a Kurd living in the country with his wife, teenage daughter Irem, and son Ismail.  In the apartment above them was an American family: the father Marcus, the teenage son Dylan, and the wife who dies saving Ismail in the earthquake.  When Americans, led by Marcus, set up a refugee relief area for those affected by the quake, Sinan and his family join the many others living in tents.  But the new situation also allows for a growing relationship between Irem and Dylan that will have repercussions for both families.

Musings: Gardens of Water is a story of two individuals torn between what they want and believe.  For Sinan, that means balancing his love for his children with his religious and cultural beliefs, and his preference for his son with his conflicting feelings about his daughter.  In the refugee camp, no longer in a role as provider of the family, Sinan must confront these conflicting feelings for the first time.  Meanwhile, the teenage Irem tries to balance her desire for freedom from the life her mother has led with her unwillingness to give up her family, culture, and religious beliefs. The novel shows that there are no easy answers for either individual, but that, inevitably, choices have to be made.

What I like most about Gardens of Water is it's full-fledged characters, from Sinan and Irem to Marcus and Dylan.  No one is a true hero or villain, as each one struggles with her or her own frustration, failings, and attempt to make sense of the universe.

Surprisingly for a book built on character development, the action moves quite quickly.  Short chapters and alternatively following Sinan and Irem keep the pace quick, even though the book centers around Sinan as a whole.

I know very little about Turkey and the conflict with the Kurds, and nothing about the 1999 earthquake, and I enjoyed learning more.  Although the author is an American, it felt as though all the characters were treated with respect as individuals with important similarities and differences.

Negative Reviews

Note: I wrote this post on Friday, but I wanted to edit it, so I didn't publish it yet.  Then, I read this post, "I Love Bad Reviews", by Justine Larbalestier this morning.  And she said what I wanted to say, but better. That's what I get for waiting! I'm still posting mine, but I highly recommend reading Justine's thoughts on the matter.

Every couple months the blogs seem to blow up about the issue of negative reviews (I've only seen this in the YA blogs, but perhaps it happens elsewhere). I feel pretty strongly about the issue, so I thought I'd share.

First, I think it's a problem if bloggers look at reviews as a service to authors to help improve the authors' writing.  Authors have plenty of people to help them with their writing--crit partners, writers' groups, agents, etc. Truthfully, it seems pretty egotistical to think whatever you have to say is going to be so monumentally earth shattering that it will drastically improve the author's future writings.  If you see problems, the author most likely a) already knows or b) doesn't see them as issues.  Therefore, writing reviews with an author audience in mind seems wrong.

So, that means book reviews are for two basic purposes:
1) To allow you to express your thoughts on books
2) To inform other readers about books

Both of these are worthwhile and important purposes.  I write my reviews because I desperately need somewhere to get out my thoughts (my husband only wants to talk so much about books he hasn't read!).  The OCD part of me likes the style, organization, and feeling of culmination reviewing each book I read gives me.  I read many other blogs to be informed about books I might like to read.

So here's the thing--if book blog reviews are for those two purposes, then I see no reason not to write critical reviews.  If I review to express my thoughts and then lie about a book that stunk, then I'm not achieving purpose one.  And if I write a more positive review than the book deserved, then I'm failing to accurately deliver on purpose two.

My absolute least favorite types of reviews go something like this: "Yelping Chihuahua Archers by Suzy McSaddlepants was an amazing book.  The story hooked me and the style was so amazing it took my breath away.  I highly recommend this book to everyone I know! It gets 15/10 triple sundae heart points!"  Because if all you do is uniformly praise every book you read (and what the heck does "the style is so amazing" mean?), then your reviews are completely meaningless.  (I will make exceptions for blogs that announce upfront that they will only review books they love.)  To me, you become untrustworthy as a source.

Now, like most others who have weighed on this issue have noted, I don't advocate trashing an author ("McSaddlepants is a total loser and should obviously leave the writing profession and instead become a grave digger, dig her own grave, and die.") or trashing a whole genre because of an author ("Saddlepants' failure to write a compelling young adult dystopian post-modern Western clearly demonstrates that the genre is tired and overdone.").  However, I think it's okay to be critical.  It's even okay to come across as harsh.  You're writing to express your own thoughts and to pass those along to readers--and I want the truth.

I've written a number of harsh reviews.  I loathed The Tattooed Girl (from my review: "This book is terrible. Truly, terrible. Not boring terrible, dense terrible, or cliched terrible- just terrible.") and One Hundred Years of Solitude ("One Hundred Years was an intolerable continuum of tedium."), and I said so in my reviews.  Of course, Oates and Marquez are famous, well-recognized writers, and neither book is YA.

But I also criticized recent YA releases like Wildthorn and The Line because I did not feel they were good books.  I try to specify why, since certainly aspects that bother me might not bother another reader.  But, as a reader, I don't want to waste my time on something I won't enjoy, so I appreciate knowing the faults up front.

I do have a couple things that make it easier to write what I think: I have very low blog readership and I don't hope to become a published author. I suppose if I had tons of readers ready to pounce should I say something wrong or was sending out queries I might be more paranoid and thus cautious.  I'm also not receiving ARCs to review, and like it or not, I think being a common recipient of advance books (and wanting to continue to be a recipient of such) probably does play a role in the way reviews come out.

So, here is my final thought: YA community, please keep writing thoughtful, critical reviews.  The best of YA doesn't get recognized if everything that comes out is deemed absolutely fabulous.

Thursday, March 3, 2011

"Before I Fall" by Lauren Oliver

Summary: Sam, a high school senior, has the perfect life: three absolute best friends, a cool boyfriend (with whom she plans to lose her virginity tonight), and complete popularity.  When driving home with her friends after a night of partying, she's involved in a crash--and wakes up to relive the same day once more.  As Sam lives through one day of her life seven times, she realizes the mistakes she's made and seeks to correct them.

Musings: Before I Fall is a mash-up of Mean Girls and Groundhog Day that, despite treading no new ground, still manages to be compelling.  In fact, the greatest strength of Oliver's writing is that even though the book falls into well-trod characters (the alpha-popular girl; the bullied loner) and themes (popularity isn't what's most important; be yourself!), the characters still feel full-bodied and important to the reader.

The narrator is Sam (i.e. Cady from Mean Girls, once she's popular) a girl who, when the book starts, is a total bitch, just like her friends (notably Lindsay, a.k.a. Mean Girl's Regina George).  Of course, being popular, she and her friends don't actively recognize how cruel they are.  However, I liked that the girls aren't only defined by their cruelty.  They're also honest to goodness best friends, supportive and devoted to one another.

As Sam begins reliving one day of her life, she predictably begins to notice her many faults, recognize what's truly important, and become a better person.  But this standard narrative is also broken up by many mishaps and well-intentioned but hurtful mistakes.

The new love interest, the adorable Kent, is probably too perfect (I said the same thing about Alex, the love interest in Oliver's Delirium--darn you, Oliver, for giving us perfect guys who will never exist), but I can never resist a pining relationship, and it was sweet to see their relationship begin several times over.  Nonetheless, it's not the romantic relationships, but the complicated female friendships that really form the center of the book. (double darn, I said almost the same thing about Delirium too!)

I know this is a book that my 14-year-old female students would love, and I enjoyed it too, despite the overly-exaggerated emphasis on popularity (I know I never looked gaga-eyed at seniors when I was a freshman, though I didn't talk to them either).  The ending may hint to easier solutions than the real world can provide, but it's also an ending that relies on hope, which I can't criticize.

Sunday, February 27, 2011

"Complications" by Atul Gawande

Summary: A collection of essays on the tricky and uncertain science of surgery and medicine.

Musings: I found Complications on a list of engaging nonfiction, and Gawande's work did not fail me in that regard.  In fact, I found his book more engrossing than much of the fiction I read. I think this is because medicine is an area that pervades our lives despite the fact that many of us know so little about it. Gawande's book is then both reassuring and frightening, for it details the way in which there is so much doctors and scientists don't know as well.

The first section of the book is on surgeons specifically, where Gawande discusses the training of doctors and the "complications of medicine"--how things go wrong and how difficult it is to prevent and predict those occurrences. The second and third sections address disease, with individual chapters on things such as gastric bypass surgery, SIDS, pain, and nausea.

The medical terminology is all explained in layman's terms but without making the reader feel like an idiot.  And although the book is not for the overly squeamish, disease and surgery are described straightforwardly, not grotesquely.

Probably what brings the book most to life, however, is Gawande's personal presence.  A surgeon himself, Gawande's stories of his experiences with patients fill every chapter, and he uses his own challenges as a spring board to examine larger issues at play.  In the afterward Gawande credits writer Malcolm Gladwell as a supportive friend, and I could see something of Gladwell's style in the book (whether that's because of the friendship or because both write for The New Yorker, I don't know). Like Gladwell, Gawande's essays all follow a similar structure: begin with a narrative, introduce the personal, analyze with scientific evidence, and return to narrative.  Nonetheless, the repetitive structure doesn't lessen the reader's fascination with the myriad topics Gawande explores.

I highly recommend Complications to anyone looking for fast-paced nonfiction or insight into modern medicine.

***This book qualifies for the POC Reading Challenge.

Friday, February 25, 2011

"Redwall" by Brian Jacques

Summary: The Redwall Abbey has long been a peaceful place for all woodland creatures.  However, when the ruthless rat Cluny the Scourge discovers the abbey, he determines he and his minions will take it.  Matthias, a young mouse of Redwall, knows that finding the long-lost sword of Martin the Warrior will provide the abbey's inhabitants with the needed inspiration to defeat Cluny.  Matthias must follow a series of clues to find the sword before Cluny's horde takes over Redwall.

Musings: This should probably be less of a review and more of a love letter to Jacques and the Redwall series.  I first discovered Redwall as a kid, sometime in elementary school, when I read Mossflower, which chronologically comes after Redwall.  I read a paperback library version, which, at around 450 pages, seemed huge to me.  Nonetheless, I was completely sucked in and read the entire book in one sitting.  I was so entranced that once I finished, I begged my mom to take me back to that library--right at that instant--in order to pick up Redwall, which I also finished in the same day. I probably read eight or so books in the series (there will be 22 as of May) before reaching those teenage years when I read little, but Jacques' stories have always had a special place in my heart.  With the recent news of Jacques' passing, I knew I wanted to return to the Redwall world again.

Redwall is the perfect epic story of good heroes defeating evil villains.  Redwall is a multi-cultural paradise where all woodland creatures--mice, badgers, otters, squirrels--exist in harmony.  But despite the essential goodness of all the characters, the protagonists don't feel boring or simple.  There's the determined Matthias, willing to take on a leadership role despite his young age.  The strong and stubborn Constance the badger is probably my favorite character, followed closely by the experienced fighter rabbit Basil Stag Hare.  It's hard to choose a favorite character because the world is so richly populated.

As much as the Redwall citizens are good, the villain Cluny is truly evil.  My husband pointed out how effective Jacques is at making Cluny terrifying despite the fact that he never really has any success at taking over the abbey.  And, truthfully, I like that about the series.  It's not a series for very young kids--there are violent battles, terrified characters, and even some deaths.  But the books are never tragic, hopeless, or morose.

Could I do some critical analysis of the series?  Perhaps.  And I'm sure there's something to say for the division of "good" woodland creatures and "bad."  In the end, though, I think that's rarely going to matter for the reader.  Redwall is a rousing adventure in a world the reader can't help but want to inhabit.  Who doesn't want to jostle among the bickering shrews or scale walls alongside Tess the squirrel?  Then there's the food! Anyone who has read the series knows that just as the fights and quests are epic, so are the feasts, which are so fully described that the reader immediately becomes hungry.

I hope to read these books aloud with my children some day, and I'd like to continue to reread the series myself.

Sunday, February 20, 2011

"A Hundred Thousand Kingdoms" by N.K. Jemisin

Summary: There were once three gods.  But the god Itempas killed the god Enefa and imprisoned the third god, Nahadoth.  Now Nahadoth and his children are enslaved weapons of the Arameri, the ruling people of the Hundred Thousand Kingdoms.

Yeine has been raised with her father's family in Darr ever since her mother--sole heir to the Arameri throne--was disowned after giving up her heirship to be with Yeine's father.  Both of Yeine's parents are now dead, and Dekarta, Yeine's grandfather and current ruler, has recalled Yeine to Sky in order to name her potential heir, along with two of her cousins.  In Sky Yeine learns what it means to be Arameri for the first time while becoming uncomfortably close with the enslaved gods, particularly the seductive god of darkness, Nahadoth.

The gods and the Arameri clearly all have plans in place--and Yeine must decide her role in the future of the world.

Musings: The summary above is much longer than the summaries I typically write, but that's because there's so much going on in The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms that it's difficult to even know where to start.  The complex nature of the novel is one of its greatest strengths and occasionally a hindrance.  The depth of the mythology and characters of Hundred Thousand Kingdoms makes it such an engaging read, but there's so much of interest that inevitably some areas are unexplored.

Jemisin's greatest achievement is her ability to create an entire back story--to the gods, the Arameri, and Yeine--that comes together in a compelling narrative. There's so much going on that at times I did feel a bit lost, but everything comes together in the end.  I especially liked the richness of the gods' histories and the way in which they seem mortal and not-mortal, understandable and unfathomable.  Most people today think of God (or gods) as an unreachable, perfect being, but these gods are more like those of Ancient Greece--all the more powerful and deadly because of their semblance to humans. Like American Gods, Hundred Thousand Kingdoms addresses what happens when a god is no longer at the pinnacle of power, something I found especially fascinating.

Yeine is the perfect protagonist, a strong woman from the matriarchal Darr who is thrust into a world she doesn't understand.  She finds herself pulled in many directions, and only slowly does she (and the reader) come to make sense of the world around her.  Her relationship with Nahadoth is unusual and intense, but I appreciated that it isn't her only relationship in the book--her friendship with the godling child Sieh and the Arameri servant T'vril are also significant. 

The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms is definitely high fantasy, and some people might be put off by the complicated world building, as well as the violence and sex.  However, for me, the novel came together perfectly, and I finished it far more quickly than any other book I've read recently.  Yeine's strong voice is completely compelling, and I think most any reader would find the book hard to put down once begun.

***This book qualifies for the POC Reading Challenge.

Wednesday, February 16, 2011

"Winter's End" by Jean-Claude Mourlevat

Summary: When Helen, Milena, Bart, and Milos run away from their restrictive boarding schools, they know the danger they're facing.  The Phalange government is after them, and, in the end, only three are able to join up with the Resistance.  As Helen, Milena, and Bart work to overthrow the cruel Phalange regime, Milos finds he is being prepared to fight to the death in a gladiator match.

Musings: Winter's End has some nice dystopian elements, though in the end I think it will be a rather forgettable novel.  The book begins at the girls' boarding school and describes the school's strange practices; rules are numerous and the only real joy the girls get is from their thrice a year allowed visits to "consolers," motherly women who comfort the girls during their two-hour visits.  There's a nice creepy atmosphere at the school, and truthfully, I would have liked to have had more of the action there.  I also wanted more information on who the consolers are and how the magical "Sky" came to be, both of which aren't explained.

Instead, the story quickly moves into the town, which is under the rule of the Phalange.  The ruling group is not really explained, nor are their governing practices, beyond being obviously cruel.  This makes the middle section of the book somewhat dull.  It's clear that the Resistance will eventually try to overthrow the government, but without any unique world building there's little of interest. Milos' experience in the gladiator training camp is somewhat more interesting, primarily due to the unique characters he is housed with.

The four teenage characters are fairly dull and interchangeable, and the dialogue between them feels stilted and fake.  I don't know whether that's because of the book itself or the English translation (the book was originally published in French), but it reminded me of dialogue in books from the '20s ("Oh, yes, we shall!", etc.).  There's supposed to be romance, but there's not much passion felt.

Winter's End is diverting enough, but the most interesting parts of the book--the boarding school, the horse-men--are relegated to the sidelines.

- Read as part of Presenting Lenore's Dystopian February.
***Book received from the publisher at the NCTE Conference in 2009.