I'm somewhat ambivalent about the novel. There's certainly some on-point racial satire, particularly around the way Buck's co-workers' surface-level geniality masks underlying prejudice. The book as a whole, though, feels so extreme that it's hard to get invested. Part of that extreme comes from the hyper-emphasis on sales as the end-all-be-all of life (the book is even framed as a "manual" for readers to learn sales). Part of the problem with Sumwun is its single-minded belief in the importance of its work. As if selling more subscriptions for teletherapy makes any actual difference in the world. Now, this is a problem in corporate business in general--the intensity of the work giving the illusion that the work is meaningful--but the book doesn't do much to dispel the myth. It also suggests sales is the solution for all problems. Darren teaches a few people sales over a couple days and--voila--they're successfully hired in business. It ignores all the gatekeepers--college degrees, internships, etc.--and suggests success is simply a result of tenacity.
And that's the biggest issue I had with the novel. Sure, it's quite aware of racism in American, but its counter to that is to revert back to a straightforward American Dream ideal. In the world of Black Buck, sales success is a result (solely) of bravado. And how do you learn bravado? You do crazy stunts like walk pass police drinking open beer cans and then run away. By that logic, teenage boys should be the most successful humans on the planet. Or, you demean and abuse people, and "what doesn't kill them makes them stronger." Uh... I certainly agree that confidence, swagger, and the knowledge of how to persuade another person are incredibly useful skills. But the book rarely teaches how to actually learn those skills. Instead, Darren takes a group out to an expensive dinner and then they skip the bill. They make a limited attempt to persuade the waiter that they shouldn't pay, then run away. How is that teaching sales? How does that make the group anything but jerks?
Darren's inconsistencies as a character and the convoluted ending also dampened my spirits for the novel. The book is so extreme that I think it shines less light on race and the business world than it could have.
No comments:
Post a Comment